A reply from Boots

You may recall that I recently sent the Customer Care Team at Boots a photo of my shredded up Boots Card, in protest against their well-documented tax avoidance strategies. Well, I received a reply:

Dear Mr Butler,

Thank you for getting in touch with us. I’m sorry to hear of your surprise and disappointment that Alliance Boots has offices outside of the UK and I’m grateful for this opportunity to share some insight into this matter.

Boots is part of the Alliance Boots group of companies.

Alliance Boots, as well as owning the Boots and the Boots Opticians shops in the UK also owns substantial and extensive pharmaceutical wholesale and pharmacy-led health and beauty activities outside the UK.

As a pharmacy-led health and beauty company with extensive international pharmaceutical wholesale activities, Alliance Boots works very closely with most of the world’s leading pharmaceutical manufacturers, many of which are based in Switzerland.

Naturally, we have offices in every country where we have customers. We believe, however, that having Alliance Boots’ corporate head office in Switzerland with the proximity that brings to many major pharmaceutical companies, including Galenica, a Swiss manufacturer in which Alliance Boots has a substantial investment, enhances Alliance Boots’ position as a leading international pharmacy-led health and beauty group.

Alliance Boots is committed to the local communities in all countries in which it has operations. In the UK, many 10’s of thousands of people work in the pharmaceutical wholesale and pharmacy-led health and beauty retail activities of Alliance Boots group companies.

Regarding Alliance Boots’ tax position, I would like to confirm and reassure you that Alliance Boots and the companies of its group comply fully with all applicable tax laws in each of the countries where they do business, including in the UK.

Alliance Boots group companies are substantial tax payers in the UK and Alliance Boots is today paying substantially the same amount of tax it would have paid had it kept its head office in the UK even though substantial operating and financial costs have been sustained to create the conditions for the relaunch of Boots and the development of Alliance Healthcare in the UK.

In the meantime, I would like to thank you for your trust and custom with Boots and to re-assure you that we always do business in accordance with all applicable laws and with the highest ethical standards.

Kind regards

Ryan Jamison
Senior Customer Manager
Boots Customer Care.

So this is what I’ve gleaned from this email: I’m angry that Boots have the nerve to operate outside of the UK (I’m not), and Boots only upped and moved their Head Office to Switzerland because they have some good chums out there and the chocolate’s lovely.

Right.

UK Uncut made a good point when I forwarded this on to them:

This is clear bull. If this was true, they would be pushing libel charges on Radio 4 for saying they would be paying between 80 and 100m less in tax every year.

Britain’s libel laws are brilliant and always absolutely fair. So much so that the UN felt compelled to give us a pat on the back in 2008. Companies and individuals have been known to come to our fair land to take advantage of them, instead of using their own country’s. Think of it as libel tourism.

Of course we know I’m talking rubbish, and that UK Uncut are bang on. In terms of libel laws, Britannia really does rule the waves. With an iron fist. Time and time again, the lunacy of our overly stringent libel laws has been used to give legitimacy to cases that should have been laughed out of court. If there were even the slightest discrepancy in Radio 4’s statements, Alliance Boots would  have been all over them like Richard Littlejohn on a vocal minority.

The line about how they found the goodness in their hearts to employ so many Brits also made me laugh, considering it was only back in October that they are to cut 900 jobs due to ‘restructuring’.

So, having picked Ryan up on a few little points, let’s move on to his main argument: Boots are fully compliant with UK tax laws, and are thus doing nothing wrong.

We know that Boots aren’t breaking any laws. None of these tax avoiders are. That’s why they pay clever accounting teams so much money: to avoid paying as much tax as possible whilst remaining legal. No one’s  disputing the legitimacy of your operations, Boots.

But legality and morality aren’t always on the same side. Those of you who were lucky enough to study Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice at school might remember Portia eloquently chokeslamming this notion in court.  But why rely on literature? There are plenty of real world examples. ‘Marital rape’ was exempted from being recognised by the UK’s rape laws right up until 1991. Before the repeal of this exemption, many men were let off with lesser sentences for assault;a relic from the days where the wife was the man’s legal property, and he could do what he bloody well wanted with/to her.

All too often, the law turns a blind eye to the actions of those who have all of the cards.

This is why there have been protests. Not because what they’re doing is illegal, but because it is dishonest. I’m on to you, Boots. It will take more than a nicely worded email to get me to sellotape my Advantage Card back together.

“If you want a picture of the future, imagine Boots stomping on a human face — forever.” — George Orwell, 1984 [sort of]

2 thoughts on “A reply from Boots”

  1. “If you want a picture of the future, imagine Boots stomping on a human face — forever.” — George Orwell, 1984 [sort of]

    haha I came up with that joke quite possibly the same day you posted this blog, as inspired by your previous post on Boots?!?!

    Proof of the existence of the Jungian collective subconscious above or just a shared penchant for silly puns? ONLY TIME WILL TELL!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *