When I was growing up, my family were very into watching boxing. What better Saturday night entertainment than watching two men beat the living shit out of each other? Its appeal was so great that we were willing to chip in to Rupert Murdoch’s yacht fund to watch the pay-per-view title bouts. The pre-fight trailers would promise a no holds barred grudge match. But given the human tendency to avoid getting hurt, this was rarely the case. Instead we would watch two trained professionals take part in a damage limitation exercise. Lots of blocking, dodging, and hugging. Eight year old Liam was (disturbingly) disappointed by the fight not living up to the hype, and I haven’t learned my lesson.
The BBC knew they didn’t have to do much to hype up last night’s Question Time. Book in Nigel Farage (increasingly resembling an ice sculpture of Nigel Farage that’s been left out in the sun for too long and then had a load of dogs piss on it), throw in one Russell Brand (increasingly resembling that guru who The Beatles would go visit), and the hype will take care of itself.
It was a lot like a title bout: lots of dodging and blocking, a bit less hugging. While everyone wanted to see a slugging match between two tabloid titans, the other guests weren’t going to be marginalised. Both Brand and Farage realised that they stood to gain more from keeping quiet. Early on, Brand was called out by fellow panelist Mary Creagh (Labour) for shouting over Penny Mordaunt (Conservative). After that, he didn’t say much unless prompted. Nigel Farage, on the other hand, didn’t need to get his point across. He just sat back and smiled contentedly while Labour and the Conservatives bickered over who had the toughest stance on immigration.
The BBC were quick to jump on a heated exchange where Brand called Farage ‘a pound shop Enoch Powell’, tweeting a shareable quote:
Russell Brand says we should be wary of politicians like Nigel Farage. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/sBSmuGHNvp
— BBC Question Time (@bbcquestiontime) December 11, 2014
That was when it looked like it was going to kick off, but it didn’t. Brand and Farage settled down, and the audience picked up the slack. Shouty Blue Haired Woman vs Shouty Man With Cane was easily the most exciting part of the evening.
The papers are already running stories about them. By Monday they’ll each have a hit YouTube channel, and by next Friday they’ll be in a tear-jerking supermarket ad where they put aside their differences for Christmas.
Both Brand and Farage were evasive. Instead of engaging with the questions, they’d pick the part they liked and fitted their agenda around it. While I sympathise more with Brand’s politics than Farage’s, it was deflating to see him behaving like a politician and not really giving a straight answer.
But I’m kidding myself. Politicians and celebrities don’t go on Question Time to answer questions, just like I didn’t tune in last night to hear questions being answered. I wanted to see Farage and Brand go head to head, while Brand, Farage, and the BBC just wanted to raise their profiles. Looks like it’s only the viewer who lost out. But just like the disappointment never stopped my Dad from paying to see the next title bout, I doubt I’ll stop watching Question Time.

