On one of my many Google instant searches, I stumbled upon a site called ‘Dandy Designs‘. A “gallery of God’s handiwork”, this site claims to show examples from nature which unequivocally prove that God designed everything. You can probably see how much respect I hold for this notion by the fact that I’ve listed this blog under ‘Superstitious Arsetalk’.
Presumably God didn’t design this blue monster of a web page.
Most of these examples are just excerpts from popular science journals or Wikipedia, where the author has added ‘and this is evidence of a creator’ at the end.
You can even buy Dandy Designs books, which bear a striking resemblence to photocopied pamphlets:
So, Science fans, let’s get our thinking hats on and look out for examples of Dandy Designs trying to fit the square peg in the round hole.
Why we see through glass and not through wood
“The complexity of this system allows us to see those things we need to see, like solid objects that our bodies cannot pass through. It also allows our vision not to be blocked by things that we can pass through, like the air or water. And it allows us to see through some solid objects which can protect us, like glass windows in our homes and cars.”
The humble eye: oft used by Creationists to show we were designed, and by Catholics as a bargaining chip against self-abuse.
This piece argues that because our eyes can only see a limited part of the electromagnetic spectrum, what we know as visible light, then this is evidence that our eyes were designed. It also argues that our eyes are designed to see through glass, because this is helpful to us. It sounds logical, but it isn’t.
Glass wasn’t designed to be see-through because one day it would come in handy for protecting us in our planet-raping automobiles, we were just able to utilise the transparent properties of glass. We utilise what we have at our disposal to make the best use of our faculties.
It’s like saying that we were given thumbs so that we would one day be able to pwn n00bs on Halo. But we all know that this isn’t the case. The thumbs came first, then we designed joypads around them.
Once we discovered how to manufacture glass, we realised that it was transparent. Were we unable to see through it, we wouldn’t have used it in the way we did. Our eyes weren’t designed to utilise glass any more than glass was designed to be utilised by our eyes. We simply discovered glass, refined it, and found it to be useful.
And as for our vision being designed so that it isn’t blocked by things we can pass through… you what? Carbon monoxide, sonny Jim. We can’t see that, but I wouldn’t recommend passing through it.
Would it not be more reasonable to suggest that our eyes have adapted over generations to only see ‘visible light’? After all, the electromagnetic spectrum’s been around a lot longer than our eyes have.
The site has got it completely the wrong way round. It suggests that nature has been designed so as to suit our eyes, whereas our eyes have been designed to suit our technological advancements. I’m interested to see how far the creator of Dandy Designs would go with such an idea…
“Your eyes were designed to see this series of still images as one continuous moving image. Your eyes were designed to accommodate television and not the other way around. Believe. BELIEVE.”
You’re a smart bunch, so I’m not going to insult your intelligence by categorically stating any more flaws in the arguments of Dandy Designs. I have every faith in your abilities as rational people to be able to do this yourself.
Go forth, and criticise.
Liam



I wonder if Dandy Designs has read this yet, and decided actually “he has a point! our eyes have been designed so that people all over the world can sit in front of a box that shows lots of pictures really quickly but as if it was not a sequence of pictures!” maybe they would then commit suicide for missing what they believe to be such a masterpiece of work by their divine creator/ designer.