I was planning to write a piece laughing at some of the more ridiculous headlines of this month’s supernatural tossrag ‘Fate and Fortune’, but I have had a spiritualist believer write a long response to my piece about a night of ‘mediumship’ that I attended. What a happy coincidence! Below is the comment in full:
Wow!!! What an onslaught, so I guess you were not overly happy ……
I feel one or two things you need to bear in mind is one in regards to the disclaimer …. Ok, so its now the law of the UK to state for entertainment purposes only – Yes, thats fine, and just another link added to the ankle chain, and ball of freedom. The spiritual movement has endured this for many centuries, and thankfully not burned at the stake any longer – So far that is 😀 If the same was applied to any other church, belief, or faith system then the political correctness of our new world may come out in uproar – So the brunt is left at the spiritual footwell.
If Mediums were to work a 40 hour week, then yes I agree that the wages of labour would be quite high, but I don’t feel that many are able to do this task as there is a lot of work in the background prior to any venues undertaken, and implemented which those outside of this field would understand, but perhaps those in business for themselves might.
Making connections with loved ones past is not quite like having a chat on the telephone, or watching TV. It is actually very draining, and hard work, and not as rewarding financially as perhaps you think.
I do not personally believe there is a Medium in the world who gets 100% all of the time, and energies can be mixed at venues where there are many people.
There are millions of people worldwide who have their faith within the spiritual realms, and this should by rights be a freedom of their choice to follow if they so choose.
I personally feel you have taken just a glance into a world that you simply do not understand, and have by this glance set yourself up as judge, jury, and executioner.
Faith my friend is having something to believe in. Obviously by your statement you have no belief in the afterlife, which of course is your right as a freedom of choice as an individual. However perhaps you should not enforce your beliefs on others or more to mar the faith of others or attempt to ridicule. It is their choice just as it is yours.
I only hope the bounds of freedom do not get any tighter than the rapid constrictions that are occuring within our country.
I hope you find some peace within whatever faith or belief system you employ for yourself in the future.
G
I think you’ll agree that they were nice enough about it, and the least I can do is try to pay them the same courtesy. Here is my reply:
First of all, G, I must assert my own belief in religious freedom. People should have a right to practice whatever belief they feel comfortable with and hold dear to their hearts. On the same token, people who do not have faith should have that choice respected by others; which, to be fair, I feel you do. However, religious freedom should also extend to being able to question others’ beliefs.
The religious freedom that you promote is an incredibly restrictive one: ‘believe whatever you wish, but never question what other people believe. That’s intolerant.’ So for all of your clichéd rhetoric aligning yourself with freedom, I can just as easily put you alongside those who are imposing, as you say, “the rapid constrictions that are occuring within our country”.
The fact of the matter is that Trevor, Wendy, and all other ‘mediums’ make a rather large claim. One that could affect our whole perception of our finite time on earth. They claim that this life isn’t everything, and when we die our spirits will go to some other place where we will still be able to communicate with the living from time to time. Now, that’s a very big claim without looking into the implications that such a claim creates. When any claim is made, people should be able to ask ‘why? How have you come to that conclusion? What evidence do you have to support it?’
Hiding behind the right to religious freedom is an intellectual cop-out.
By that logic, I could start saying that I hold a deep religious belief that Girls Aloud’s Sarah Harding is capable of photosynthesis. Instead of proving my assertion, I could turn round and say that people who question this belief would be impinging on my right to religious freedom.
A doctor could say that injecting cyanide into people’s knees is a good way to cure cancer, and that this is a matter of religious faith for him. Some patients will probably go along with it. After all, the doctor claims to be very experienced in his field. Despite the doctor having no evidence to support this wild claim, should everyone allow him to inject cyanide into cancer patients for fear of offending the doctor’s religious sensibilities?
George W. Bush said that he believed God told him to pursue the War on Terror, should we not question this for fear of intruding upon his right to believe what he believes?
There is a difference between questioning the beliefs of others, and forcing your beliefs on to another. Crying foul when someone questions your beliefs simply highlights your own insecurities about your belief and your inability to justify your standpoint. And I will take this approach with any religion that has beliefs that I feel should be questioned, not just spiritualism. So please: don’t liken me to an inquisitor. I’m asking a question, not tying you to the stake.
After that unimpressive night of ‘mediumship’, I could have simply wrote a straight refutation of what Trevor and Wendy had claimed to do that night. However, if you haven’t already noticed, this is a blog where I’ve tried to entertain people and make them laugh– only my readers can be the judge of whether I’ve been successful.
So yes, I was damning and vitriolic towards Trevor and Wendy. Why? I was angry. I was angry that a couple who made such big promises to their audience could only resort to cold reading, obeying the law of averages, and, if all else failed, snappily asserting that they were right and the audience member was wrong. I saw them do this to many people in the audience, including me. It came across as cynical, calculating, and mercenary. Perhaps they do genuinely believe in what they do, but from what I saw I don’t think so.
I’m glad that the UK has laws that make ‘mediums’ assert that their show is ‘For Entertainment Purposes Only’. Personally, I’d like the law stretching to make these entertainers actually say this at the beginning of their show. And yes, I take your point that not many ‘mediums’ can get a 40 hour week of ‘mediumship’. But you can’t be telling me that none of them would jump at the opportunity, given the chance? They’re just the same as gigging musicians, playing venue after venue in the hope of getting noticed and getting big. There are enough ‘mediums’ doing sold-out arena tours to show that there are opportunities for that profession to pay well.
John Edward seems to have made a nice little nest egg with this whole talking to dead people malarkey.
You’re right, I don’t understand ‘mediums’. That’s why I ask questions. And whilst it could be seen as unfair of me to dismiss the entire spiritualist movement based on my experiences, where exactly can I draw the line? I could visit one fraudulent ‘medium’ after another, and yet I could still be told that I haven’t seen enough of it to properly make up my mind. However, all that’s doing is putting off the inevitable. And that is concluding that there is no objective evidence to support the claims that ‘mediums’ make. Perhaps one day someone will find objective proof of the spirit world and our ability to contact it. On that day I’ll be the first to put my hand up and admit that I was wrong, and I’ll stop writing ‘medium’ in inverted commas.
Until then I’ll keep asking questions.

LOVE it. 🙂
Couldn’t agree more Liam. We have to ask questions of beliefs we don’t understand, otherwise we will never understand them. Also, if we think someone is wrong, just accepting what they believe achieves nothing except to make ourselves look stupid: http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=820#comic
Ohhh……SNAP!
p.s. Love you long time, Liam.
Hiya Liam, I have tried to question many religious corners myself, but always get a quote by return even though I have never actually asked the men (or ladies) of the cloth for proof in this regard.
Personally I do not promote any religion Liam, and just voicing my own opinion as you are. The freedom of which I spoke is not restrictive, and believe that all religions or individual faiths are our rights to behold even with the hierarchy, and rules which may be governed within any particular area for the masses.
Whether one follows the Bible, Kabbalah, Koran, or any other of the thousands of followings out there, if one wishes to follow or none at all or perhaps one of their own then I personally feel this is entitlement.
Outside of many a Christian establishment is advertised Jesus Saves, and although this is a part of my own belief system I would certainly question, but unlikely to ask for proof as this in itself is a biggest part of faith. On the other hand if I didn’t like what I saw I also doubt if I would enter their realms anyway, and just let them get on with their choice without interference.
Claims are made on a daily basis in all walks of life, and yes most are unable to prove it.
There are frauds in all walks of life without exception I presume, and this I also presume may include the spiritual field also, yet to the genuine medium it is not just a faith, they know for sure of the life hereafter, and assist in their work by helping those within this particular belief system.
Yes I agree with you that there are some of the major players who are making good, and yes they bring this to the wider audience, and yes again just like all major players within any sphere.
I just felt that with attending one venue you were just a little quick off the mark to condemn, and with placing this on the google search thus making it public, you could perhaps be harming anothers reputation needlessly.
Having served through several Miners Strikes it bestowed me the purpose of never wishing harm to others which might result in their loss or injury to their livelihood.
I know you are angry Liam, but negative intent serves no purpose.
I did not reply to your posting in order to win the war of words, you have done that handsomely. I am just an individual who felt injustice toward another without full consideration being in place.
Hi G. Again, thanks for a balanced and pleasant response. I’ll just make a few further points:
If by exposing fraudulent behaviour in the public sphere I have done something atrocious, what about shows like ‘Watchdog’ and ‘Don’t Get Done, Get Dom’? Those shows often catch out frauds on television. By your assertion these shows must be weekly atrocity exhibitions, ruining one man’s livelihood after the next.
What would you suggest? If someone gets one dodgy kitchen from a cowboy builder, they shouldn’t be so quick to judge and should get the builder to install another one? I can see Dominic Littlewood shaking his little bald head in disbelief. To paraphrase Bob Dylan: ‘how many bodged kitchens must a dodgy kitchen fitter install, before he is surely a dodgy kitchen fitter?’
And furthermore, would you argue that the cowboy builder’s livelihood is at stake, and that it would be unfair to say anything that would possibly “result in loss or injury to their livelihood”? What about all those people with badly fitted kitchens that the fitter has left in their wake?
Trevor and Wendy’s website shows one glowing testimonial after the next. Now, I’m sure not everyone goes away from Trevor and Wendy’s shows with such a good impression. My Mum and I certainly didn’t. They bullied people into agreeing with their assertions– there’s no two ways about it. I’ve just shown the other side of the coin.
Finally, on the point of your ‘live and let live’ stance towards religions. Yes, that’s all well and good in theory. But there are several horric practices out there that have had some religious significance tacked on to them. The inhumane practice of female circumcision springs to mind. Maybe we should just let those who practice this to mutilate young girls, exposing them to a serious risk of infection and later complications at childbirth? Definitely not.
By asking ‘why exactly are you doing that?’– instead of just saying ‘oh look, they’re mutilating that young girl. How devout.’– we are not practicing religious intolerance, we are simply getting people to rationalise and justify what they are doing. If they can only hide behind scripture, and cannot express the significance of what they are doing in their own words, then alarm bells should be ringing.
We have gotten a lot further by asking ‘why’, ‘how’, and ‘what for’, then we ever will achieve by blind faith alone. That’s what I believe.
G, you do seem like a genuinely nice person, and I’ve a lot of respect for what you did at the picket lines. But I still think that ‘mediumship’ is a cynical exploitation of the needy.
All the best,
Liam
I understand that G feels that his personal beliefs are being attacked, and i guess that if i didn’t know Liam or read this blog regularly, and had only read that one blog post on Liam’s trip to see Trevor and Wendy i might see it that way too.
But G you should understand that Liam’s blog is all about is bringing intellectual humour to the sad truths of the world.
Yes Liam is a rather opinionated person, but everyone has opinions on different things, if everyone thought the same and believed the same things then we would probably have disappeared from existence a long time ago, evolution is all about (as Liam said) asking why, what and how, (that is of course assuming that you believe in evolution).
I bet there are far more fake ‘mediums’ in the world than there are genuine ones, and because of these fakes and their dodgy ‘shows’ of course you will get a lot of people who doubt in the existence of mediums at all.
That particular blog post was more about Trevor and Wendy and their shocking ‘performance’ and how they, and people like them, affect peoples belief in mediumship by faking readings and messages.
In any walk of life one experience with a bad ‘professional’ can tarnish the whole profession for a person, when we where children my sister had a really bad hair cut by one hair stylist, and for years refused to go near any salon, and even cut her own hair.
And i know many people that have had a bad experience with a dentist and now hate going to any dentist.
Does this mean all dentists are evil? of course not, but unfortunately one bad experience can change a persons opinion for life.
I would personally love to see you in action, maybe Liam would to, maybe you could even help change the poor guys tarnished opinion of mediums…. although maybe we would be asking a bit too much with that one. 😉
“Poor guy”? Honestly, Shell. You’ve made some great points here, but am I a “poor guy” for not believing in ‘mediums’?
I also don’t think that anyone who swears as much as I do can be said to be making ‘intellectual humour’.
But still. I’m flattered.
Liam
A private one to one Reading from J.Edwards is £750, and a pretty long wait at that – However I doubt many are able or indeed willing to part with such sums.
Mediums in Yorkshire fee’s are around the £20 – £30 area inc travel expences for a full Reading, and this is probably the best way to go.
A good ethical Medium would not charge you at all if the connection was not made, and this can be discovered probably within 5 mins or so. An audience is quite different, and not one to walk away from so easily, and mixed energies can mean the information received could actually be for someone else in the audience plus other factors even like the place where one is reading, along with the receptive, and openness of the sitter.
I do not feel my personal faith system is under attack, and would never allow this in itself to bother me. However when one is publicly dished without full justification be it faith or anything else then yes I get my protector shield out in others defence. The fact that the initial post was planted on open Google makes this with intent, and if as you say bringing intellectual humour to the sad truths of the world is fine providing this is not with malice at anothers expence. This in itself invites Karma.
Most mediums would not wish to change anothers mind, or persuade – That’s control. However they are there by invitation in many circumstances, and many donate a part of their fee to charity along with many who are willing to work for charity events without fee.
Some good points are in the making of your words thanks Shell, and many of these I feel are made by our conditioning.
Whilst fingers are pointed in one direction, the rest are left alone.
Liam flattered – Yes I believe he possibly is …..
I fight against the conditioning systems, and freedoms which have been ebbed away by our so called hierarchy which is gathering at a now greater pace. In a way not too dissimilar from Liam’s injustices, and hurts over this lifetime (or was it previous ;). However I personally prefer to face, and act whenever possible to prove my displeasure, but on the other hand maybe that’s coz I’m just an ol’git who never grew up :-/
A quick point on Google:
Google works by sending crawlbots throughout the web which find public web pages and add them to the Google archives. This is an automatic process and requires no input, especially as WordPress is very well integrated with Google.
It wasn’t a case of me sitting down one day and submitting the URL of the original blog about Trevor and Wendy to the front page of Google. If it was that simple then rest assured I’d be putting all of my blogs on Google’s front page.
The intent towards exposing them as fraudulent only extends as far as me putting the blog online.
I wish I was as good with Google as you think I am.