Miss the rain?

I recently heard the 90’s dance pop classic ‘Missing’, by Everything but the Girl.It was the first time I’d heard it in years. It used to really annoy me when I was eight, due to the lyric “I miss you like the deserts miss the rain”. Fifteen years on and it still winds me up. Why? Deserts don’t miss rain. In fact they have adapted to survive perfectly adequately without it.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s a lovely metaphor. But I like my metaphors to be able to withstand cross-examination. Though you’d be forgiven for thinking those arid lands would rejoice when visited by a cumulonimbus, the truth is that they’ve been able to cope in the absence of rain. Desert life, much like Gloria Gaynor, has adapted and survived. It doesn’t mind the fleeting attention the rainfall gives, but it can do just as well without.

cactus_001

The humble cactus. It spreads its roots far and wide. Sure, when the rain comes it will enjoy itself, storing up that watery goodness for a long time, the lack of leaves helping to reduce water loss. This plant don’t need no rain’s attentions. If they could speak– which they wouldn’t, in order to conserve water– but if they could speak, they would probably just say “I depend on me”, over and over again. It’s like Destiny’s Child had cacti in mind when they got someone to write ‘Independent Women’ .

mycamel1

The resilient camel. You won’t hear any complaining about a drought from this one. See how it looks upon the horizon, unfettered from rain’s clutches. The camel is so cocksure of not needing water to survive that it has made a habit of disdainfully spitting, repulsed by its fellow mammals’ dependence on rainfall.

As I hope to have shown, deserts don’t miss rain at all. Were they to suddenly become the object of rain’s attentions, they would be overwhelmed and would probably die.I’m sure that isn’t the image that Everything but the Girl were aiming for.

You may find this kind of pedantry to be unnecessary– and if so, I’m sorry for wanting to live in a world where metaphors can withstand sustained scrutiny.

Evidently that’s asking too much.

One thought on “Miss the rain?”

  1. You have summed up my thoughts on this metaphor perfectly. I came across your post while searching online to see if anyone else shared my feelings about this song. I am glad that I am not alone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *