Rain or shine, they’re there every Saturday morning. They stand at the corner of Market Square in my local town, ensuring that passers-by are aware of the teachings of Christ. Once upon a time I’d have walked on, but, disciple of Dawkins and Darwin that I am, I decided to engage them in debate. I soon realised that I don’t have the killer instinct to go for their theological jugular. Some people are just too nice, and I’m too polite.
I won’t name the two women that I was speaking to; that wouldn’t be fair. But it quickly became clear that they earnestly believe in what they’re doing. They are utterly convinced that God is going to judge each and every one of us, and if they don’t act there’s going to be a lot of people getting cast down. They stand there with their signs every weekend, hoping to heal and enlighten. They are inviting, pleasant and courteous.
There wasn’t much that we actually agreed on. They find the prospect of sharing an evolutionary ancestor with a chimpanzee to be ridiculous and horrifying. They believe that we are all born with an albatross of original sin around our necks. They believe Noah actually had an arc, and it was recently uncovered by an archaeological dig in ‘some mountain’. They believe homosexuality is utterly sinful. They describe our world as one that is slowly slipping into chaos, and they believe that irreligion is the cause. And don’t get them started on abortion. I found it hard to reconcile their convictions with my own.
Sometimes I struggled to keep my childish side at bay. I had to suppress a derisive snort when they said that they watch the God Channel in earnest. I could have screamed in frustration at the implication that carbon dating is a scientific conspiracy to suppress religion. What stopped me? It was politeness in part. But they were also lovely. Utterly, utterly lovely.
They are the kind of women that you want as grandmothers. There was kindness in their eyes. Their weathered faces creased into the most lovely smiles. They were genuinely saddened that I wasn’t able to have the personal relationship with Jesus that they had. They gave me a hug at the end, and earnestly believed, somewhat patronisingly, but in an endearing way, that their prayers would save me. None of this gives any validity to what they were claiming, but it did make it harder for me to tell them that.
At this point, you may be wondering why I even bothered. They’re obviously firm in their convictions, as am I. Why did I engage in what would inevitably be a stalemate? Because it’s good to be open. I believe that engagement and debate are constructive, and that questioning your beliefs and those of others can only be a good thing. Science isn’t a game of absolutes; it’s a process of refinement and discussion. Whereas some religious organisations brazenly call non-believers fools on railway posters, one atheist slogan retorted, far more tentatively, that there probably isn’t a God. I’m open to the possibility of a God, hence why I’m happy to enter into discussions, but at this moment in time I have to deduce from the overwhelming mass of evidence that it’s more than likely that God doesn’t exist.
But try telling them that. Those two women have endured hardships and suffering that nobody should have to endure. They claim that these personal experiences give irrefutable evidence of the existence of a higher power. Science has a name for that. It’s called ‘anecdotal evidence’, and it isn’t looked upon too highly. But when you’re was actually there, looking another human being in the eye, their voice shaking with emotion as they share their accounts of the darkest moments of their lives and their salvation, it becomes somewhat difficult to turn round and say that personal experience isn’t admissible as evidence. Today, I discovered that sometimes it’s easier to just walk away.
They say that they don’t stand there to try and convert people, but they do. And I can try lying to myself and say that I wasn’t trying to convince them that God doesn’t exist, but I was. I wanted to be able to go away with the smug satisfaction that I had won. But you can’t win with that kind of person, just like they would struggle to convince me. It was ridiculous of me to think otherwise.
When I first started reading more about atheism, I saw it as a quest to rid the world of religion and its many evils. I’m starting to see things differently now. Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens don’t run around pissing in fonts and trying to drag the devout kicking and screaming into Godlessness. They’re polemicists, politely putting across their side of the argument, making sure that people are aware that there is another side to the argument. That’s all that can be done. Anything else is just a waste of a good Saturday morning.
But I’m still going after the ‘mediums’ with the force of a jet propelled freight train. Those cynical parasites deserve no mercy.

I have never, ever seen these people. Nor have I ever seen ads for mediumship in Driffield! I’m missing out on so, so much.
You’ll find them both towards the less busy side of town. The mediums’ ads are regularly put up outside Silks, and the Street Healing Team are always outside the Water Margin on a Saturday morning.
You need to come back from York more often.