Sadness is something that comic books don’t seem to be able to do very well.* Maybe it has a lot to do with the name of the genre, not to mention its newspaper funny page origins. Comics can do most other emotions with depth and feeling, but not sadness. One rare gem which bucks this trend is Jason Aaron’s Scalped— my favourite ongoing comic series.
*- I am, of course, omitting Maus from this sweeping observation.
Scalped is set on the Prarie Rose Reservation in modern-day South Dakota. Forgotten by the federal government, its inhabitants wallow in crime and poverty. For many, the traditions and pride of yesteryear have been lost in a haze of alcoholism, bitterness, and unemployment. Amidst the infertile lands and shanty housing, an expensive new casino has been built by a tribal chief with a life story that would make the Krays bend on one knee and declare him The Daddy.
And there isn’t a superhero to be found.
The story is what you would expect from crime fiction; corrupt double dealings and backstabbing occur on the sides of law enforcement and crime syndicates alike. The art, with its murky colour palette, sets the scene perfectly. But, as I said before, what really stands out is the sadness. As you may expect from such a hopeless setting, misery is in no short supply. This is where Aaron’s storytelling really comes into its own. He has an uncanny ablity to endow each character with the depth for them to develop and show some true feeling. They never feel like caricatures, instead they feel like individuals, each with their own conflicts, drives, secrets, and burdens– an achievement not to be sniffed at with a medium which delivers itself in monthly, 30 page increments.
Part crime fiction, part social essay, Scalped refuses to pander to what we expect from an issue-by-issue comic. If Scalped wants to dedicate an entire issue to how an ancillary character may dream of getting off the reservation, but will never succeed, then Scalped dedicates an issue to this. If Scalped wants to dedicate an issue to the seemingly hopeless situation of an unborn baby with a crack addict for a mother, then it will. You don’t get quick fixes here; no monthly 25 pages of build up followed by a cathartic 5 pages of panel-to-panel action. Here, storytelling takes the priority. You get action, but it’s given in controlled quantities. Scalped isn’t for the faint-hearted, but it’s also not for the easily distracted.
There has been some controversy as to whether this is an accurate picture of Native American reservations, or if it is noirish sensationalism. Like most crime fiction, it’s probably somewhere in the middle. But I don’t really feel qualified to answer this, given that my knowledge of the Native American people doesn’t extend much further than Dances With Wolves.
Watching this constituted half of the syllabus for the ‘Native Americans’ topic in year 8 History. No Joke. We also watched Witness for a topic based around the Amish for year 11 Religious Education. Again, no joke.
All I know is that I have been following this comic for the best part of two years now, and I still feel excited when I can get my hands on a new collection. It’s the characters.
Character development is what elevated The Sopranos into the Hall of Fame. Every now and again, Tony would do something that surprised you. Something that you would never have expected him to do, but which seemed to fit in perfectly with his character. It was a degree of insight that you don’t see too often in popular entertainment. It’s here, in Scalped. From the act of compassion from the chief you were about to write off, to the acts of brutality from those whom you would never expect it, I felt that same feeling of astonishment that I felt when watching Tony do that-thing-after-the-car-accident in the final series of The Sopranos.
Maybe the bleakness stirs my morbid curiosity, or maybe it’s because Scalped chose a setting largely untouched by comic writers. I don’t know. What I do know is that as I glean more insight into each character, I crave each issue more than I did the last. If you can get your hands on this, and are willing to put the time in, then you will be rewarded with one of the best comics of recent years.

