Last night, for the first time since Monkey Dust went off the air, I tuned in to BBC Three.
I watched First Time Voters’ Question Time, or, as the little bar at the bottom kept calling it FTVQT. I don’t know what it is about producers trying to get at the youth demographic, but do they really think the way to do it is to bury us under a ton of acronyms? FTVQT? FFS.
Being the wanker that loves to scoff at the failure of others, I thought I was in for a treat. Sadly I was disappointed. Despite the best efforts of the producers, First Time Voters’ Question Time was actually an interesting nugget of television.
I say ‘despite the best efforts of the producers’ because some of their attempts to be “with it” were just painful. Look at the show’s logo. Just look at it:

Garishly coloured background. Conventional block lettering brought into stark contrast with letters cut out of a newspaper. Nope, never seen this anywhere before. *COUGHNEVERMINDTHEBOLLOCKSCOUGH*
Hosting the show we had The X-Factor’s own Mr. Charisma, Dermot O’Leary. A man whose only other experience of televised politics came about when Simon Cowell was accused of keeping Jedward in the competition for the ratings boost. I can almost see the FTVQT producers’ brainstorming session now:
“Right. So we’ll do an edition of Question Time for the kids. Any ideas?”
“Lose Dimbleby. He looks too much like Great Uncle Bulgaria from The Wombles.”
“Good idea. Who shall we get?”
“Are that ‘Pendulum’ lot available to host? That banging they make seems to be very palletable to the young lot.”
“No. I think they’re touring. How about Mr. Tumble? My kids love him.”
“Get Dermot O’Leary. He’s free at the moment. Yeah, the kids see him as one of them.”
Alongside Dermot we had political satirist and impersonator Rory Bremner, Apprentice winner Tim Campbell, Higher Education Minister David Lammy, Shadow Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt, Lib Dem Communities Spokesman Julia Goldsworthy, and… Jamelia. Yes. Jamelia.
It seems that the producers were worried that if we didn’t see someone close to our age on the panel, then we’d switch off. Must have just been a case of finding a young musician who hasn’t been on T.V for a while.
So I sat down to watch, ready to laugh. And you know what? The buggers only went and proved me wrong, didn’t they?
Dermot had done his research. Big time. He’d been able to make valid points and was able to rein participants in when they got too off topic. He was also able to shut the politicians up when they began gasbagging about how they hated the expenses scheme by pointing out what they themselves had claimed. He showed himself to be a very capable host, whilst still maintaining his likeability. Yeah, he definitely sent me packing with my tail between my legs. Thanks the the format of the show and Dermot’s professionalism, it wasn’t the tacky patronising youth fest that it could so easily have become.
Rory Bremner was, as always, well informed and to the point. He was capable of cutting the politicians down when they started making false promises. The reason I’m not saying more about him is because he performed brilliantly.
He’s not just a pretty face, you know.
Just last week a friend and I were discussing whether leaving her 2:1 English Lit degree off her CV would improve her short term chances of getting a job. No one is going to employ someone who they think will just up and leave when the job market picks up. This is where The Apprentice’s Tim Campbell came in. He argued that Labour’s great university experiment had failed, and that we need to give more consideration to vocational training and entrepreneurism. Given the current job situation, I can’t argue with that. I also liked his up front manner, pointing out when the politicians were skirting around an issue.
And that brings me to the self confessed non-voter Jamelia. You know what? She was bloody good, too. It was obvious how nervous she was. I wouldn’t blame her for feeling out of her depth. But by the end she made some very valid points, including bringing the politicians to task for constantly fishing for votes in future elections as opposed to doing something now.
She’s not just a peddler of bland R&B, you know.
The show’s weakest link was definitely the politicians. I’m not giving them separate segments because they don’t deserve them. Often, they weren’t communicating with each other, instead being far more interested in petty one-upmanship. A question would be asked and they just wouldn’t answer it. It was like watching a Samuel Beckett play. They had pre-prepared responses and just tried to match them up to the questions as best as they could. It didn’t matter that it was a triangular shaped hole and they only had a square peg, they were determined to make it fit.
Take this example 36 minutes in. A guy in a green jumper (with what looked like a lovebite on his neck) asked how they expect young people to vote when all the political parties are saying the same thing. He was talking, of course, about the similarity of all the parties’ policies these days, compared to the bygone eras where you know clearly that Labour stood for the workers and the Conservatives stood for the rich. Instead the politicians decided to answer imaginary questions about how wrong the tribal nature of politics is, how terrible the expenses scandal was and how they had nothing to do with it and were visiting relatives that day, and finally they made some vague murmuring about voter apathy.
Their rambling became so bad that sometimes Dermot couldn’t get them back on track. At these points the director would cut to shots of young and attractive audience members looking thoughtful.
As they were discussing youth unemployment, voter apathy and the value of degrees, the topics on the show were, for once, interesting and relevant to me. The politicians, however, were not. There was no personality there. They just looked like three career politicians making empty stabs at being passionate and appealing to the youth demographic. It was a sad thing to see on the same day that Michael Foot died.
The huge gap in the market that a show like this tried to fill is only accentuated by the recommendations that iPlayer tried to give me after watching this show:
Yehh, us kidz r well up 4 watchin Andrew Marr b4 watchin sum fake tan minga on Snog Marry Avoid
Do they really expect young people who watched this show to be avid viewers of Andrew Marr and Snog Marry Avoid? There is a lack of shows catering for young people who are interested in issues that affect them, and after last night’s show I can see how it can be filled successfully.
Just ditch that bloody logo, BBC. Don’t try to be edgy. Just give it to us straight. Come on, we can take it. We’re big boys and girls now.


